Sunday, October 5, 2014

Illusive Identity

"I'll pack my bags and brush it off"
     -Mayday Parade, "Call Me Hopeless, Not Romantic"

How do we claim our identity? With our close friends, we express ourselves through our personality and behavioral reactions. But from a bystander's point of view, we are labeled by our physical appearance.

Judgments based on outward appearance are inevitable in human nature. Even when reading a passage describing a character or person, it is difficult to not base the character's identity on their looks. In the passage read this week in class, Tannen describes the appearances of three women in a business meeting. She plainly depicts each woman nonjudgmentally, deceiving readers into judging each one. "The third wore a sexy jumpsuit; tight sleeveless jersey and tight yellow slacks; a dress with gaping armholes and an indulged tendency to fall off one shoulder" (Tannen 6). Readers can infer that this woman is promiscuous and daring, just by the way she dresses. This conveys how physical image affects a person's identity. We concluded the woman's personality unfairly based on her looks, never allowing her a chance to express her traits.

Louis Vuitton Bag
Outward appearances are categorized by the typical personalities of the wearers. For example, if a woman owns many designer brand handbags, such as Louis Vuitton, Coach, or Michael Kors, she is labeled by society as "luxurious" and "wealthy". If a man has his ears pierced, sags his trousers, and wears clunky boots, he is a "bad boy" or a "gangster". Since it is assumed that most "gangsters" or "lavish" women dress in these ways, anyone who dresses in a similar way to them is associated with their characteristics. This instigates societal judgments of appearance, because everyone dresses in a certain way and ultimately is classified. Although we can hypothesize someone's identity based on their physical aspects, true identity is only shown through someone's actions and personality.

6 comments:

  1. Hi Sarah,
    I completely agree. Many people assume that our outward appearance is a reflection of who we are on the inside. There are many times that this is true, but there are also many times when it is not. However, trying to look around one's outward appearance is risky, and vulnerability is not something anyone wants to feel. Thank you for blogging about this topic!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I find this post to be true, mainly because I feel at times that some of my closer friends are judged in this kind of way. I feel that this also applies to men, even when Tannen states that all men are unmarked.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like how you show the truth in our harsh realities. But also, I like how you bring out examples to help us understand your point.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey Sarah, I definitely understand what you are trying to convey. I think you developed great ethos by citing specific brands of clothes!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think that your examples are spot on with brand names, but the stereotypes also apply to bags that look more "in style". Still no matter what bag you have, or don't have- you'll be judged.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree with your definition of identity and I can relate to being categorized by outward appearances. I also liked how you not only related this to girls, but also to guys.

    ReplyDelete